Não tenho muito a dizer sobre o novo livro de Frank Miller. Do que li e reli, tudo me parece unânime. As fontes são fiáveis, toda a gente as conhece. Parece-me que o senhor anda zangado e que ainda não se resolveu, como tantos outros seus compatriotas. O resultado é um livro inútil, que no inicio parecia ter pernas para andar, por ser um livro sobre o Batman e os seus inimigos, não sobre terroristas e estadunidenses.Enfim, fica uma crítica do conceituado Newsarama, que casca forte numa mente outrora brilhante, mas que anda por meandros obscuros. Ora leiam:
"Holy Terror is a mean and ugly book. It's a cartoonist lashing out at an easy and broad target without seemingly understanding the target. The book doesn't look at the villains in any way or explore the differences between Muslims and terrorists. It's not even concerned about defining the heroes and villains in any terms other than "right" and "wrong." Holy Terror is a book about anger and pain that is blind to anything other than revenge. There's no attempt to define the villains beyond the fact that they don't look Iike you and me. Holy Terror isn't a book that tries to be real. It just wants to lash out, thinking that that is the only response to the attacks of 10 years ago."
Retirado do site Newsarama, onde podem ler na totalidade a notícia.
O Ain´t it cool news ainda é menos bondoso:
"Arrogant. Arrogant god-damn bastard. Sloppy, arrogant work by an arrogant bastard. Frank Miller. Always building himself up bigger, taller, like some mad gaggle of robots. Always climbing. Now falling. Enjoys repetition and small sentences. Originally a proposed Batman book, this is now...something else. Instead of Batman and Catwoman and Gotham City: The Fixer and Natalie Stack and god-damn Empire City. Cold. Wet. Noisy. Haughty. But all I read is failed Batman, failed Catwoman, Failed Gotham City."
O resto aqui.
Fico a aguardar um Frank Miller com melhores dias, quer seja na 9ª ou 7ª Arte.
Mauro Bex : maurobindo
"Holy Terror is a mean and ugly book. It's a cartoonist lashing out at an easy and broad target without seemingly understanding the target. The book doesn't look at the villains in any way or explore the differences between Muslims and terrorists. It's not even concerned about defining the heroes and villains in any terms other than "right" and "wrong." Holy Terror is a book about anger and pain that is blind to anything other than revenge. There's no attempt to define the villains beyond the fact that they don't look Iike you and me. Holy Terror isn't a book that tries to be real. It just wants to lash out, thinking that that is the only response to the attacks of 10 years ago."
Retirado do site Newsarama, onde podem ler na totalidade a notícia.
O Ain´t it cool news ainda é menos bondoso:
"Arrogant. Arrogant god-damn bastard. Sloppy, arrogant work by an arrogant bastard. Frank Miller. Always building himself up bigger, taller, like some mad gaggle of robots. Always climbing. Now falling. Enjoys repetition and small sentences. Originally a proposed Batman book, this is now...something else. Instead of Batman and Catwoman and Gotham City: The Fixer and Natalie Stack and god-damn Empire City. Cold. Wet. Noisy. Haughty. But all I read is failed Batman, failed Catwoman, Failed Gotham City."
O resto aqui.
Fico a aguardar um Frank Miller com melhores dias, quer seja na 9ª ou 7ª Arte.
Mauro Bex : maurobindo
